• 5 Posts
  • 11 Comments
Joined 1 year ago
cake
Cake day: July 8th, 2023

help-circle
  • EmilieEvans@lemmy.mlOPto3DPrinting@lemmy.worldNEMA34 upgrade
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    3
    ·
    1 day ago

    Shaft diameter and length is also part of it.

    NEMA is just a mechanical aspect and contains zero information about the performance. Equally comparing motors by torque isn’t the full picture as the inductance (and other aspects) can be different. Equally important is the stepper-driver & supply voltage.





  • EmilieEvans@lemmy.mlOPto3DPrinting@lemmy.worldNEMA34 upgrade
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    4
    ·
    edit-2
    2 days ago

    I see. Size doesn’t matter to you. It is all about skills.

    Let’s me introduce you to the 400W NEMA24 servo.

    edit: Sorry. Was only the 400W unit. Somewhere there should be a 750W speciment.

    Also be careful with these motor. While a small NEMA17 found on 3D-printer has 0.5 Nm and under normal conditions will stall before serious harm happens this NEMA34 is 9Nm which is enough to break bones. Those 400W servos are equally dangerous. While only around 1Nm they have roughly 4Nm peak and keep this torque at high RPMs.




  • Get a BambuLab P1S without AMS.

    I don’t want to be bogged down with having to run proprietary slicers through Wine and things like that. I am not sure how big of an issue that is with e.g. Bambu or Creality (if at all), but I’ve seen enough rug-pulls and enshittification processes that I don’t really want to risk that.

    You can use PrusaSlicer, OrcaSlicer, Cura or some other slicer with them. They run perfectly fine in LAN-mode removing the Bamub Lab server stuff/question from the equation.

    While not every replacement parts are also made by third party companies things like nozzles, PEI-sheets or fans are available from third parties.

    As future-proof as I can possibly hope for.

    I would argue money in the bank account is far more future-proof than any 3D printer can be and Bambu Lab costs a fraction of what a Prusa core one costs. So when the future arrives use the saved money to buy a next-gen printer.

    Locally produced (I’m EU based).

    Bambu Labs are well made so not a safety hazard but I can understand this point.

    The Prusa core one looks very promising but at the same time, it isn’t for everybody and the general consumer is likely better of by buying the P1S. For the price of 1 Prusa One you could buy 2 Bambu Lab P1S and 10-20kg of good PETG.

    regarding Support: Difficult question. Prusa has excellent support but the last experience I had with their printers before dropping them wasn’t that great and was riddled by issues/bugs. BambuLab on the other have the it just works magic but the support needs to improve. You send them a bunch of log files as requested. They probably only look at the oldest file (that might be months old) and provide a “wrong” reply based on that as a solution without looking at the text you wrote.